Tilbury Consulting Ltd v Gittins (2004): an early contractor IR35 victory

Roger Tilbury provided specialist IT consultancy services through his company, Tilbury Consulting Ltd.

He worked on Ford projects for around nine years. But Tilbury did not contract directly with Ford. He was one of the specialists used by Compuware to deliver services under its own contract with Ford.

HMRC argued that a direct relationship between Tilbury and Ford would have been one of employment.

Special Commissioner Stephen Oliver QC disagreed. Tilbury Consulting won its IR35 appeal in November 2003.

Tilbury Consulting won its IR35 appeal. Compuware was providing services to Ford as a principal contractor and Tilbury worked as part of that arrangement. Control over his services lay with Compuware rather than Ford, and the Special Commissioner found that Tilbury had not become part of Ford’s undertaking.

Nine years working on Ford projects

Compuware had been contracted by Ford to provide technical services. It assembled the people needed to deliver them, using both employees and specialists supplied through limited companies.

Tilbury was one of those specialists.

He worked on Ford projects for around nine years and alongside other people involved in delivering work for the company.

HMRC argued that the intermediaries legislation applied to the arrangement.

The Special Commissioner had to consider the hypothetical contract which would have existed between Tilbury and Ford if Tilbury Consulting were removed from the chain.

Compuware wasn’t simply an agency

Compuware’s role was central to the case.

It had contracted with Ford as a principal to provide services and was responsible for putting together the resources needed to deliver them.

Tilbury was therefore not simply an individual contractor introduced to Ford by a recruitment agency. He was one of the specialists Compuware used to fulfil its own obligations to Ford.

Who controlled Tilbury’s work?

Ford could specify the services it wanted from Compuware, but the evidence did not show Ford exercising substantial control over how Tilbury performed his specialist work.

The Special Commissioner found that, to the extent that control was exercisable over Tilbury’s services, it lay with Compuware rather than Ford.

Tilbury worked within Compuware’s delivery arrangements rather than under Ford’s direct management.

See our guide to control and IR35.

Tilbury wasn’t part of Ford

HMRC also relied on Tilbury’s long history of working on Ford projects.

The Special Commissioner found that Tilbury had never become part and parcel of Ford’s undertaking.

He had been there for around nine years, but remained one of the resources used by Compuware to provide its services to Ford.

See part and parcel and integration.

Substitution

Tilbury Consulting had a qualified right to provide a substitute, although Tilbury never used it.

This was different from Express & Echo Publications Ltd v Tanton, where the contractual right to provide another driver meant that personal service was not required.

In Tilbury’s case, the substitution provision sat within an arrangement in which Compuware itself was responsible for supplying resources to Ford.

See our guide to the right to provide a substitute.

Why Tilbury won

The Special Commissioner found that a direct contract between Tilbury and Ford would not have been a contract of employment.

Compuware had engaged Tilbury as part of the services it supplied to Ford. Control over his work lay with Compuware rather than Ford, and Tilbury had not become part of Ford’s undertaking.

Tilbury Consulting also had a qualified right to provide a substitute.

The appeal was allowed.

Tilbury and later IR35 cases

Tilbury was decided at Special Commissioners level in 2003.

Later decisions including Dragonfly Consultancy Ltd v HMRC, Atholl House Productions Ltd v HMRC and Kickabout Productions Ltd v HMRC provide more authoritative guidance on the hypothetical contract and employment status tests.

Tilbury had worked on Ford projects for around nine years when his company won the appeal.

Judgment

The substantive IR35 appeal was decided by Special Commissioner Stephen Oliver QC on 3 November 2003:

Tilbury Consulting Ltd v Gittins (No. 2) SPC 390, also reported as [2004] STC (SCD) 72.

An earlier preliminary decision concerned the issue of a witness summons rather than the merits of the IR35 appeal:

Tilbury Consulting Ltd v Gittins SPC 379.