S & Barnes Ltd v HMRC (2024) – Stuart Barnes Sky Sports IR35 case

S & L Barnes Ltd v HMRC concerned Stuart Barnes’ rugby commentary and punditry work for Sky Sports between 2013 and 2019.

Barnes initially won before the First-tier Tribunal in January 2023. HMRC appealed, and the result was reversed in HMRC v S & L Barnes Ltd [2024] UKUT 262 (TCC). The Upper Tribunal remade the decision and found that the hypothetical contracts between Barnes and Sky were contracts of employment.

Around £695,000 in PAYE and National Insurance was reportedly at stake.

The dispute was decided at the third stage of the Ready Mixed Concrete test. Mutuality of obligation and sufficient control had already been established. The Upper Tribunal’s decision turned on the remaining terms of the hypothetical Sky contracts, including Sky’s right of first call on Barnes’ services, restrictions on other work, the absence of substitution and Barnes’ limited financial risk.

Barnes’ work for Sky

Stuart Barnes had played rugby for England, Bath and Bristol before establishing a career as a commentator, pundit and journalist.

His company, S & L Barnes Ltd, supplied his services to Sky Sports. During the same period Barnes also wrote newspaper columns and carried out other media work.

Barnes had considerable freedom when giving his opinions and analysis. Sky had engaged him for his rugby knowledge and distinctive broadcasting style rather than to tell him what views to express.

The contracts nevertheless gave Sky substantial rights over his availability. In particular, Sky had a right of first call on Barnes for up to 228 days a year. There were also restrictions concerning other media work.

The First-tier Tribunal finds for Barnes

The First-tier Tribunal released its decision in January 2023 in S & L Barnes Ltd v HMRC [2023] UKFTT 42 (TC).

It accepted that the hypothetical contracts contained sufficient mutuality of obligation and a sufficient framework of control. The case therefore moved to the third limb of the Ready Mixed Concrete test.

Here the FTT found for Barnes.

His work outside Sky was important. Barnes had an established reputation as the “voice of rugby”, wrote newspaper columns and had other commercial activities. The tribunal found that these activities supported the case that he was in business on his own account.

The FTT also dealt with Sky’s contractual right of first call. It found that the contractual arrangements had effectively been varied so that Barnes could continue with his newspaper work.

Taking the remaining terms and circumstances into account, the FTT concluded that the hypothetical contracts were contracts for services. S & L Barnes Ltd won its appeal.

HMRC appeals

HMRC challenged the FTT’s treatment of the hypothetical contracts and its application of the third limb of Ready Mixed Concrete.

The Upper Tribunal appeal was heard by Judge Scott and Judge Baldwin. Their decision was released on 28 August 2024.

The treatment of Sky’s first-call provision was an important part of HMRC’s appeal.

Sky’s right of first call

The written arrangements gave Sky first call on Barnes’ services for up to 228 days each year.

The FTT had treated that provision as having been varied to accommodate Barnes’ newspaper commitments. The Upper Tribunal found that there was insufficient evidence for the hypothetical contract to contain the variation adopted by the FTT.

This changed the terms which then had to be assessed at the third stage of Ready Mixed Concrete.

Barnes could carry out other work, but Sky retained significant contractual rights over his availability and other media activities. His work elsewhere did not remove those terms from the hypothetical Sky contract.

The other terms of the Sky engagement

The Upper Tribunal considered Barnes’ work for Sky over a number of years, the first-call provision and the restrictions applying to other media work.

There was no right of substitution. Sky had engaged Barnes personally and expected him to perform the work.

Barnes also bore little financial risk in his Sky engagements. Although he had other commercial activities and an established media career, those activities did not alter the financial terms on which he worked for Sky.

His professional independence was considered as well. Barnes had considerable freedom over what he said on air and how he expressed his rugby analysis, but that was only one part of the contractual relationship being examined.

The Upper Tribunal remakes the decision

The Upper Tribunal found that the FTT had made errors in its third-stage assessment and set aside its decision.

Unlike Basic Broadcasting Ltd v HMRC, where the case was remitted to the FTT, the Upper Tribunal was able to remake the decision itself.

It weighed Barnes’ reputation, his newspaper work and his wider business activities against the terms of his relationship with Sky.

The first-call commitment, restrictions concerning other media work, lack of substitution, long duration of the relationship and limited financial risk supported employment. The Upper Tribunal found that these outweighed the factors which had led the FTT to find for Barnes.

The hypothetical contracts were therefore contracts of employment. HMRC’s appeal was allowed and S & L Barnes Ltd’s appeal against the tax assessments was dismissed.

Barnes and other Sky Sports cases

The decision can be compared with other IR35 disputes involving Sky presenters and pundits.

In McCann Media Ltd v HMRC, the tribunal considered Neil McCann’s work for Sky Sports. PD & MJ Ltd v HMRC concerned Phil Thompson’s work as a football pundit for Sky.

Albatel Ltd v HMRC reached the opposite result on Lorraine Kelly’s ITV engagements. Her contracts and working arrangements were different.

Barnes and Atholl House

Barnes’ work outside Sky was relevant to the third-stage assessment. The Upper Tribunal did not disregard it.

The question was how that wider business activity fitted with the terms of the hypothetical Sky contracts. Following Atholl House, those terms had to be established before the remaining Ready Mixed Concrete factors were assessed.

For Barnes, the terms retained by Sky carried greater weight than his newspaper work, wider commercial activities and reputation as an independent rugby broadcaster.

Judgments

The First-tier Tribunal initially allowed S & L Barnes Ltd’s appeal in January 2023:

S & L Barnes Ltd v HMRC [2023] UKFTT 42 (TC).

The Upper Tribunal allowed HMRC’s appeal and remade the decision on 28 August 2024:

HMRC v S & L Barnes Ltd [2024] UKUT 262 (TCC).