Lime-IT Ltd v Justin (2002) – the first major contractor IR35 win

Lime-IT Ltd v Justin was an important early IR35 win for an IT contractor.

Lisa Fernley provided IT consultancy services to Marconi through her company, Lime-IT Ltd, with Executive Recruitment Services plc (ERS) sitting between the two.

HMRC argued that Fernley would have been an employee of Marconi if she had worked for the company directly. Special Commissioner Dr John F Avery Jones disagreed.

Lime-IT won its appeal in October 2002.

Lisa Fernley’s Marconi contract

Fernley formed Lime-IT Ltd in April 2000 to provide IT consultancy services, together with hardware and software support.

Shortly afterwards, the company began supplying her services to Marconi through ERS.

The contract ran from April 2000 to April 2001 and estimated that Fernley would work around 37 hours a week. In practice, her hours depended on the work that needed doing.

Some weeks she did no work for Marconi. In others she worked more than 50 hours.

The work was organised around projects with expected completion dates. Fernley was brought in for her specialist skills rather than to fill an existing Marconi position.

Why did Lime-IT win? Fernley’s Marconi work looked like a consultancy engagement. Her hours followed the projects, she had considerable freedom over the work, Lime-IT had other clients and its own business equipment, and Fernley was kept separate from Marconi’s employees.

HMRC’s case

HMRC looked at the arrangement without Lime-IT and ERS in the middle.

Its case was that a direct contract between Fernley and Marconi would have been a contract of employment and the engagement therefore fell within IR35.

The length of the engagement, the time Fernley spent at Marconi’s premises and the working arrangements were among the points relied on by the Revenue.

The investigation itself had not gone particularly well. The HMRC officer, Mr Justin, told the hearing that he was unhappy with aspects of the way the case had been handled and apologised for the inconvenience caused.

The work was project-based

The nature of Fernley’s work was important.

She was engaged to work on particular projects rather than simply being added to Marconi’s IT staff. The projects had expected completion dates and the hours needed to complete them varied.

The Commissioner recorded weekly hours ranging from zero to 52.5.

That was quite different from an arrangement where a worker was expected to turn up for a fixed working week regardless of the amount of project work available.

Marconi’s control

Marconi naturally had some control over work being carried out on its projects, but Fernley was an experienced IT consultant and was not closely supervised in the way she did the technical work.

Her hours were driven by what was needed to complete the projects. There was no requirement for her to work a fixed 37-hour week simply because the contract contained that estimate.

The Commissioner did not find the degree of control expected in an employment relationship.

See our guide to control and IR35.

Lime-IT had other clients

The Marconi contract was not Lime-IT’s only business.

The company provided services to four other clients while Fernley was working for Marconi.

Fernley also had a dedicated home office containing several computers and other equipment used for the business.

She bought a laptop costing around £1,600 for the Marconi work even though the contract did not require Lime-IT to provide one.

These were useful facts when the Commissioner considered whether Fernley was operating a business rather than simply selling her labour to Marconi.

Late invoices and financial risk

Lime-IT also had the less attractive experience of running a business: customers did not always pay on time.

At one stage, more than £6,500 of invoices were overdue. Fernley threatened legal proceedings and eventually recovered the money together with interest.

The episode gave the Commissioner some real evidence of Lime-IT carrying commercial risk.

It was not simply a theoretical possibility written into a contract. Lime-IT had supplied services, issued invoices and then had to chase its customer for payment.

See financial risk and employment status.

The substitution clause

Fernley had also negotiated a substitution clause into the contract.

She never used it.

That did not make the clause irrelevant. The Commissioner accepted that it was a genuine contractual term and took it into account when considering the relationship.

The substitution provision therefore helped Lime-IT, although the case did not turn on substitution alone.

This was an important point in the early IR35 cases. A contractual right did not necessarily have to be exercised before it could carry weight.

See our guide to the right to provide a substitute.

Fernley was not part of Marconi’s staff

There were visible differences between Fernley and Marconi employees.

Her security pass identified her as a contractor and was a different colour from the passes issued to employees.

She did not receive sick pay or holiday pay and did not have access to some of the facilities available to Marconi staff, including its sports facilities.

Fernley was working at Marconi, but she had not been absorbed into its workforce.

What about Lime-IT’s wider business?

The case raised an interesting question about how much attention should be paid to work carried out for other clients.

Fernley’s position was strong. Lime-IT had other customers, its own office and equipment, and evidence of normal commercial dealings outside Marconi.

But Avery Jones did not need to rely on that wider activity to decide the appeal.

He concluded that the Marconi engagement itself pointed towards self-employment. The additional evidence about Lime-IT’s wider business supported a picture which was already apparent from the contract under consideration.

The treatment of wider business activity has since been considered in much greater detail in cases such as Hall v Lorimer and Atholl House.

An early contractor victory

Lime-IT followed the contractor defeat in Battersby v Campbell and showed early on how different the facts of two IT contracts could be.

Battersby had spent around seven years working exclusively for one bank. He was paid by the hour, used the client’s equipment, worked a normal seven-hour day and carried little financial risk.

Fernley’s position was very different. Her work was organised around projects, her hours varied sharply, Lime-IT had other clients and business equipment, and she had experienced the financial risks that came with running the company.

Synaptek Ltd v Young subsequently produced another HMRC victory.

Those early cases were heavily dependent on their own facts. Lime-IT did not create a new legal test for contractors, but it provided an early example of an IT consultancy engagement successfully falling outside IR35.

Lime-IT and IR35 today

Lime-IT was decided more than twenty years ago at Special Commissioners level. It is not the authority to use for the modern legal framework.

Cases including Atholl House, Kickabout Productions and PGMOL now provide much more authoritative guidance on how employment status should be determined.

But the facts in Lime-IT remain recognisable to anyone dealing with contractor status today: a defined project, variable hours, limited client control, other customers, business equipment, unpaid invoices and a contractual right of substitution.

On those facts, HMRC lost.

Judgment

The decision was released on 17 October 2002 by Special Commissioner Dr John F Avery Jones.

Lime-IT Ltd v Justin [2002] SpC 342 – Special Commissioners decision (PDF via egos.co.uk)