Future On-Line Ltd v Foulds (2004) – IR35 case summary

Future On-Line Ltd v Foulds [2004] EWHC 2597 (Ch) was an early IR35 case involving IT consultant Shane Roberts and his work for Electronic Data Systems Ltd (EDS).

Roberts provided his services through his own company, Future On-Line Ltd, with the agency Elan Computing acting as the intermediary between the company and EDS. He worked on a large EDS project to install a new computer system for the Department for Work and Pensions.

HMRC decided that IR35 applied to the arrangement. Future On-Line appealed, but lost before the Special Commissioners and again at the High Court in 2004.

Future On-Line lost its IR35 appeal. The High Court found that EDS was the relevant client for IR35 purposes and upheld the finding that Roberts would have been an employee if he had worked for EDS directly. The case is particularly useful when looking at control and integration, and at identifying the end-client when a contractor works through an agency.

Roberts’ contract with EDS

Roberts was an IT specialist with particular expertise in testing computer systems. He had been working through Future On-Line since 1997.

In July 2000, he started work for EDS under this contractual chain:

Future On-Line → Elan Computing → EDS

EDS used Roberts on its Child Support Reform Programme, which involved installing a computer system for the Department for Work and Pensions.

The engagement lasted until May 2003.

HMRC raised PAYE and National Insurance liabilities for 2000/01 and 2001/02 on the basis that Roberts would have been an EDS employee if the intermediary arrangements were removed.

This is the core of the IR35 rules: what would the nature of the relationship be if there were no limited company acting as an intermediary?

Was EDS the client?

Future On-Line argued that HMRC had identified the wrong client.

The company’s contract was with Elan, not EDS. On that basis, it argued that Elan should be treated as the client for IR35 purposes.

The High Court disagreed.

Roberts was an IT specialist performing work required by EDS for its own business. Elan arranged the engagement, but it wasn’t the business receiving Roberts’ IT services.

Sir Donald Rattee therefore found that EDS was the relevant client.

It’s an important point for contractors working through recruitment agencies. The agency sitting in the contractual chain doesn’t necessarily become the client for IR35 purposes. The nature of the services and who they are actually being provided to need to be considered.

HMRC still refers to Future On-Line in its guidance on identifying the client under the intermediaries legislation.

How much control did EDS have?

Control was another important part of the appeal.

Future On-Line argued that the Special Commissioner had focused on EDS’s contractual right to control Roberts, rather than on the extent of control it actually exercised.

That argument also failed.

The court accepted that Roberts was a skilled IT specialist who didn’t need close supervision. But EDS still had a sufficient right to control the work.

This is a distinction which comes up repeatedly in IR35 cases. A client doesn’t have to spend every day telling an experienced contractor how to do their job before control becomes relevant to IR35.

The position can be particularly important with highly skilled contractors, for whom relatively little supervision would be expected, whether the individual is employed or self-employed.

Was Roberts part and parcel of EDS?

The way Roberts fitted into the EDS organisation also counted against Future On-Line.

The Special Commissioner had found that he was an integral part of the EDS organisation, rather than simply an external contractor working on a project.

Future On-Line argued that too much weight had been placed on this.

Again, the High Court disagreed.

Being part and parcel of a client’s organisation isn’t a separate test that determines IR35 status on its own. However, it can be one of the factors pointing towards employment.

That was how the Special Commissioner had used it in this case.

Why Future On-Line lost

The Special Commissioner had looked at the contracts and at Roberts’ relationship with EDS. The High Court found no error in that approach.

Several findings went against Future On-Line:

  • Roberts was personally providing specialist IT services required by EDS;
  • EDS was the relevant client, despite Elan sitting between the two companies;
  • EDS had a sufficient right of control;
  • Roberts had become integrated into the EDS organisation; and
  • the terms of the hypothetical contract were consistent with employment.

The High Court upheld the Special Commissioner’s decision and dismissed Future On-Line’s appeal.

What does Future On-Line tell us about IR35?

Future On-Line is useful because the arrangement was a fairly recognisable one: an IT contractor working through his limited company and an agency for a large end-client.

The presence of the agency didn’t prevent EDS from being treated as the client. Nor did Roberts’ technical expertise and ability to work without constant supervision prevent EDS from having sufficient control.

It also shows why integration can become relevant. Working alongside a client’s staff isn’t automatically a problem, but the position becomes less helpful where the contractor starts to operate as part of the client’s organisation rather than as an independent supplier.

There is a useful comparison with Usetech Ltd v Young, another 2004 High Court IR35 case involving an agency supply chain.

Dragonfly Consultancy Ltd v HMRC later provided another example of an IT contractor losing an IR35 appeal after the courts examined the terms of the hypothetical contract with the end-client.

For the wider legal framework, see our guide to the main IR35 status tests and IR35 case law guide.

Judgment

The original Special Commissioners decision was released on 31 March 2004:

Future On Line Ltd v S K Faulds [2004] SPC 406.

Future On-Line subsequently appealed to the High Court. The appeal was dismissed by Sir Donald Rattee on 22 October 2004: Future On-Line Ltd v Foulds [2004] EWHC 2597 (Ch).