Does IR35 apply to sole traders (the ‘self-employed’)?

IR35 was introduced to clamp down on workers who set up limited companies to minimise their exposure to income tax and National Insurance liabilities, despite their working practices being more akin to those of ‘employees’.

The legislation was designed to stop individuals working through a company structure purely for tax reasons while carrying out roles identical to those of permanent staff.

As the name suggests, the legislation targeted the use of personal service companies – the ‘intermediaries’ – in the relationship between the contractor, the agency, and the end client. The rules can apply where the worker would have been regarded as an employee for tax purposes if engaged directly by the client.

For background on how IR35 evolved since 2000, see our IR35 and Off-Payroll history guide.

Sole traders and IR35

For obvious reasons, almost all discussion of IR35 matters has focused on limited companies (as umbrella company contractors are not affected).

Limited company contractors are the group most directly impacted because the intermediary structure exists, and the legislation specifically addresses this.

But what about sole traders?

While far less common in the contracting sector, sole traders do occasionally carry out project work for clients, and some businesses are open to this arrangement. However, the way status is assessed is different, and the risks fall in a different place.

We asked Seb Maley from Qdos whether or not IR35 was a consideration for sole traders.

The specific legislation only applies to limited companies (and partnerships). However, status is also an issue for sole traders. The main difference is that the end client would foot the bill if they were deemed to be disguised employees, rather than the contractor himself.

An intermediary company is interposed between the relationship between worker and end client and therefore the contractor’s limited company becomes the employer. A sole trader works directly for the end client rather than for their own company and therefore the end client is at risk of being deemed the employer.

More precisely, the IR35 legislation applies to arrangements involving an intermediary. The key point here is that a sole trader working directly for a client does not have an intermediary in the contractual chain.

This distinction explains why IR35 has rarely been framed as a sole trader issue. Employment status still matters, but there is no intermediary, no personal service company and therefore no IR35 assessment in the technical sense.

If you want to understand how HMRC makes status decisions, see our overview of the IR35 status tests, including control, mutuality of obligation and substitution.

Why IR35 rarely appears in sole trader disputes

The formal IR35 rules only apply when an intermediary sits between the worker and the client, which is why almost every enquiry and tribunal case involves a personal service company.

A sole trader doesn’t work through an intermediary.

Most large organisations don’t engage sole traders for professional contracting roles. It creates a risk that the client could be treated as the employer for PAYE and National Insurance.

Agencies take a similar view, although there is no rule preventing an agency from engaging a sole trader. The separate agency legislation may require PAYE to be operated where its conditions are met.

This is one reason why almost all case law, including the substitution disputes we cover in our substitution guide, concerns PSC engagements rather than sole traders.

Employment status still matters for sole traders

Even though IR35 technically cannot apply to a direct sole-trader engagement, HMRC still uses the same employment status framework to decide whether someone is genuinely self-employed.

Control, mutuality of obligation and being part and parcel of the client’s business remain relevant, and all are covered in our dedicated guides:

Off-Payroll Working rules and sole traders

The Off-Payroll Working rules in Chapter 10 of ITEPA do not replace IR35. They simply determine who is responsible for applying the existing IR35 tests and who is liable for any resulting tax.

For sole traders, there is no intermediary, so the client remains responsible for assessing employment status directly under normal PAYE rules.

The Off-Payroll rules only apply where an intermediary exists. Since sole traders work directly for the client, the client bears the tax risk in full.

Where genuine independence exists and the services are project-based, some clients may still engage sole traders directly. But if the relationship resembles an employment relationship, the client still risks being treated as the employer for tax purposes.

For context on how the public and private sector reforms developed, see our Off-Payroll rules guide.

When a client might safely engage a sole trader

There are some limited situations where the risks are lower:

  • The work is genuinely discrete and deliverable based
  • The contractor controls how and when the work is done
  • There is no requirement for personal service
  • The client does not integrate the worker into internal teams
  • The sole trader is not obliged to accept work outside the agreed scope

Clients still need to assess employment status. HMRC’s guidance on employment status for tax, available on GOV.UK, sets out the main factors they will look at.

Contracting as a sole trader

This once again illustrates why contractors rarely operate as sole traders. The commercial and compliance risks tend to fall on the end client or agency, rather than being shared through a company structure.

Under the agency legislation in section 44 of ITEPA 2003, an agency will generally have to operate PAYE where a worker personally provides services to a client and someone has, or has the right of, supervision, direction or control over the manner in which the work is carried out.

There is a presumption that supervision, direction or control exists unless the agency can show otherwise.

This means the agency may need to deduct income tax and National Insurance at source. It does not mean that every sole trader supplied through an agency must automatically be treated as an employee.

Agencies are understandably cautious about taking on this responsibility, especially when multiple workers are involved or when working practices resemble those of regular employees.

Some agencies will engage sole traders where they are satisfied that the agency legislation does not apply. Others only work with limited company or umbrella company contractors.

Some clients may be happy to hire sole traders directly. This tends to be more common with small local businesses or specific trades than with professional contracting roles supplied through agencies.

However, depending on the true nature of the relationship between sole trader and client, the client may be deemed to be the ‘employer’ for tax purposes according to HMRC’s employment status rules.

If the sole trader is controlled like an employee, works set hours or is integrated into the business, the client may become responsible for PAYE and National Insurance.

Tax status and employment rights are separate questions. Being treated as an employee for tax does not automatically give the sole trader full employment rights.