Carmichael v National Power plc [1999] UKHL 47 is a leading House of Lords authority on mutuality of obligation in casual working arrangements.
Although it was not an IR35 case, it is often cited in IR35 disputes where the contractor argues that there was no obligation on the client to provide ongoing work.
The claimants, Mrs Carmichael and Mrs Leese, worked as tour guides at power stations operated by National Power.
Their work was arranged on an “as required” basis.
They were contacted when tours were scheduled and could accept or decline the work offered to them. There was no guarantee of future assignments and no minimum number of hours.
The central issue before the House of Lords was whether there was an overarching contract of employment covering the periods between individual assignments.
The legal issue before the House of Lords
The claim arose because the claimants sought statutory employment protections, including the right to written particulars of employment terms.
National Power argued that there was no overarching employment contract.
The company contended that:
- there was no obligation on the company to provide work;
- there was no obligation on the guides to accept work if offered to them; and
- the documentation provided no more than a framework under which individual engagements might subsequently be agreed.
Although the written documentation described the arrangements as “casual”, the House of Lords confirmed that this label was not determinative.
The written particulars did not contain the whole agreement, so the House of Lords considered other evidence, including how the arrangements operated, to identify the parties’ contractual obligations.
The importance of mutuality of obligation
The House of Lords held that there was no overarching “umbrella” contract that required National Power to offer work or the claimants to accept it.
In that respect, there was no continuous contractual relationship spanning the periods between assignments.
The Industrial Tribunal had found that the documentation provided a framework under which successive ad hoc contracts of service or contracts for services might subsequently be made. The House of Lords restored that decision.
Importantly, however, Carmichael did not decide whether the guides were working under contracts of employment during the individual tours they actually performed. That argument had not been advanced as part of their case.
This distinction matters. The absence of an overarching contract tells us that there was no continuous employment relationship between assignments. It does not, by itself, tell us the employment status of a particular assignment.
Why Carmichael is regularly cited in IR35 cases
In many IR35 disputes, the lack of any obligation to offer future work is relied on as proof that there can be no employment relationship.
Carmichael shows why the position needs to be analysed more carefully.
The first question may be whether there is:
- a single umbrella contract which spans multiple engagements; or
- a framework under which separate contracts arise when individual pieces of work are agreed.
Carmichael dealt with the first question. It established that an overarching employment contract requires sufficient mutual obligations to exist between assignments.
The modern position on individual engagements is more clearly explained by HMRC v PGMOL. The Supreme Court confirmed that the minimum mutuality required for a contract of employment can exist during an individual engagement once work is offered and accepted, even though neither party is obliged to offer or accept further engagements.
That does not make the individual engagement a contract of employment. It simply satisfies one necessary part of the employment test. Personal service, sufficient control and the remaining terms and circumstances must still be considered under the wider Ready Mixed Concrete framework.
Overarching contracts and project-based work
In practice, tribunals examine the facts to determine whether there is a real, continuing legal relationship between assignments.
Some relevant factors may include:
- whether the parties expected work to continue as a matter of course;
- whether there were notice provisions extending beyond individual assignments;
- whether benefits or obligations accrued across engagements; and
- how the arrangement operated in reality.
If there is an overarching contract, mutual obligations may extend beyond individual pieces of work. If there is not, the status of an individual engagement may still need to be considered separately.
For IR35 purposes, that distinction can matter when identifying the terms and obligations of the hypothetical contract being assessed.
What Carmichael does not say
Carmichael did not establish a precedent that casual or ad hoc work represents employment per se.
Nor did it decide that the individual tours performed by Mrs Carmichael and Mrs Leese were contracts of employment.
Instead, it establishes that:
- the existence of an overarching contract depends on sufficient mutual contractual obligations;
- labels written in documents such as “casual” are not decisive in their own right; and
- where the written documents do not contain the whole agreement, other evidence may be relevant when identifying the contractual obligations between the parties.
In an IR35 case, the written contractual terms remain central. The approach set out in Atholl House must be followed when establishing the actual terms and constructing the hypothetical contract.
Mutuality is only part of the employment status test. Personal service, control, and the wider factors considered under the third limb of Ready Mixed Concrete remain relevant before an engagement can amount to employment.
Why is the case relevant to contractors and clients?
For contractors operating through personal service companies, Carmichael is often cited when discussing:
- short-term assignments;
- locum or sessional work;
- framework agreements with no guaranteed hours; and
- rolling contracts that are renewed periodically.
The absence of any obligation to provide or accept future work is not, on its own, enough to defeat IR35.
It may show that there is no overarching contract spanning a series of engagements. But the relevant individual engagement must still be analysed on its own terms. As PGMOL confirms, the necessary minimum mutuality can exist during an engagement even where there is no obligation to offer or accept another one afterwards.
For a broader overview, see IR35 case law, the case law hub, and IR35 basics.