Basic Broadcasting Ltd v HMRC – the Adrian Chiles IR35 case

Basic Broadcasting Ltd v HMRC is the long-running IR35 case involving broadcaster Adrian Chiles and his work for the BBC and ITV.

HMRC opened its enquiry in 2012 and eventually raised assessments for around £1.7 million in income tax and National Insurance contributions. Basic Broadcasting Ltd (BBL) won before the First-tier Tribunal in 2022, but HMRC successfully appealed two years later.

The Upper Tribunal did not decide that Chiles was inside IR35. It found that the FTT had made an error of law when considering the third limb of the Ready Mixed Concrete test and sent that part of the case back to the same tribunal panel.

HMRC v Basic Broadcasting Ltd [2024] UKUT 165 (TCC) concerned the way the FTT had assessed Adrian Chiles’ wider broadcasting business. The FTT’s findings on mutuality of obligation and control were left undisturbed. The remaining Ready Mixed Concrete assessment was remitted for reconsideration.

Chiles and Basic Broadcasting

Adrian Chiles began working for the BBC in 1992. By around 1996, the BBC required him to provide his services through a limited company, Basic Broadcasting Ltd.

BBL subsequently supplied Chiles’ services to the BBC on programmes including The One Show and Match of the Day. He moved to ITV in 2010, where his work included presenting Daybreak and football coverage, while his relationship with BBC radio continued.

The contracts challenged by HMRC covered the tax years 2012/13 to 2016/17. The question was whether the hypothetical direct contracts between Chiles and the BBC and ITV would have been contracts of employment.

The first tribunal hearing

The case had an unusually difficult route to its first decision. The original FTT hearing began in November 2019 but could not be completed. A partial rehearing took place in November 2021 and the tribunal finally released its decision in February 2022.

BBL won.

The FTT found sufficient mutuality of obligation between Chiles and the broadcasters and a sufficient framework of control. Those findings took the hypothetical contracts through the first two stages of the employment status test.

Chiles succeeded at the third stage.

Chiles had other work

During the years covered by HMRC’s assessments, Chiles did not work exclusively for the BBC and ITV. He undertook other broadcasting and commercial work, including consultancy and projects which generated intellectual property. Some of this activity ran alongside the contracts being challenged by HMRC.

The FTT regarded that wider activity as important. It found that Chiles was in business on his own account and that his BBC and ITV work formed part of that business.

It concluded that the hypothetical contracts were contracts for services and allowed BBL’s appeal.

HMRC takes the case to the Upper Tribunal

HMRC sought permission to appeal. The appeal was held up while the Court of Appeal considered Atholl House Productions Ltd v HMRC, another broadcaster case in which wider business activity was an important part of the status assessment.

The Upper Tribunal eventually heard the BBL appeal in February 2024. Mr Justice Meade and Judge Scott gave their decision in June.

HMRC won the appeal.

What was wrong with the FTT decision?

The problem was not that the FTT had looked at Chiles’ other work. The Court of Appeal had already confirmed in Atholl House that wider business activity can be relevant when the third limb of Ready Mixed Concrete is considered.

The FTT had not, however, approached that evidence in the correct way.

It first needed to establish the terms of the hypothetical contracts with the BBC and ITV. It could then consider Chiles’ wider activities as part of the third-stage assessment, subject to the rules governing which circumstances could properly be taken into account, including what was known or reasonably available to the parties.

The Upper Tribunal found that the FTT’s reasoning did not follow that approach.

It therefore set aside the decision that BBL had won.

Control and mutuality were not sent back

The Upper Tribunal’s decision did not reopen everything the FTT had decided.

The findings that the engagements involved sufficient mutuality of obligation and a sufficient framework of control were not overturned. The error occurred in the remaining Ready Mixed Concrete assessment.

That distinction matters to the next stage of the case. The remitted tribunal is not being asked to decide mutuality and control again. It must reconsider whether the other provisions of the hypothetical contracts are consistent with employment.

Why the wider business evidence matters

Chiles’ other work has not disappeared from the case simply because HMRC won at the Upper Tribunal.

His activities away from the disputed BBC and ITV contracts may still be relevant to whether he was operating an independent business during the period. The issue on remittal is how that evidence fits into the hypothetical contracts and the third limb of Ready Mixed Concrete.

This is also where Basic Broadcasting overlaps with Atholl House. Kaye Adams had substantial activities away from the BBC, and those activities were considered when her case returned to the FTT. The tribunal ultimately found that her BBC engagements formed part of a wider independent business and that the hypothetical contracts were contracts for services.

Chiles’ own stage-three assessment still has to be made on its facts.

The 2022 result did not survive the appeal

The FTT’s original finding that Chiles was outside IR35 was set aside by the Upper Tribunal.

Nor did the Upper Tribunal decide that the opposite answer was correct. It said it could not be sure that the FTT would have reached the same conclusion if it had directed itself properly, so the stage-three decision had to be made again.

The result is that Basic Broadcasting is currently an important authority on how the third limb of the employment status test should be approached, rather than a final authority that Chiles was either inside or outside IR35.

A dispute dating back to 2012

By the time the Upper Tribunal gave judgment in 2024, the HMRC enquiry had already been running for around twelve years.

The judges ended their decision by referring directly to the effect that disputes of this length can have on the people involved:

It should not be forgotten that behind every personal service company is a person, and, as we have seen in this case, the uncertainty and financial exposures generated by the difficulty in establishing a clear and stable legal position continue to produce a very real human cost.

The case was remitted to the First-tier Tribunal for the third-stage assessment to be carried out again. Until that produces a fresh decision, there is no final determination that Chiles’ disputed BBC and ITV engagements were contracts of employment or contracts for services.

Judgment

The Upper Tribunal appeal was decided by Mr Justice Meade and Judge Scott in June 2024:

HMRC v Basic Broadcasting Ltd [2024] UKUT 165 (TCC).